Mike Carrico lost to his son by less than two points, and he already knows where he'll hear about it
Most owners, asked about a loss, give you the injury report. Mike Carrico gave me a holiday.
Most owners, asked about a loss, give you the injury report. Mike Carrico gave me a holiday.
"As for Monday, we lost by a point and three quarters to my son, and I'll be hearing about it at Thanksgiving."
That sentence came near the end of a long, careful email about defensive linemen and a running back's toe, tucked in the way people tuck a sore subject between two practical ones. I have read it a dozen times since it arrived early Tuesday. It is the most human thing anyone at Fifth Quarter has said to me this season, and I don't think he meant it as anything more than a joke. That is what I like about it.
Here is what happened. Fifth Quarter hosted Kamehameha in Week 6, and the game wasn't settled until Monday night. When it was, Kamehameha had 99.32 points and Fifth Quarter had 97.56. Kamehameha had come in 0-5. The club that finally broke through belongs to Jeff Carrico, Mike's son.
I should say plainly what this story is and isn't. Jeff Carrico has not answered the questions I sent him, so everything here about the family comes from his father. This is one side. I can tell you what the scoreboard says about the son's team. I can't tell you how the son felt, and I won't guess.
The scoreboard says plenty. Kyle Pitts caught two touchdown passes for Kamehameha. Chad Ryland kicked six field goals, which in a game decided by 1.76 points is the kind of day a kicker gets to tell at his own Thanksgiving. For Fifth Quarter, Brock Purdy and DK Metcalf led the starters, and Gracen Halton, the rookie defensive lineman added from the free-agent list two days earlier, started and got a sack.
And yes, Jaylin Noel scored 21.38 points on the Fifth Quarter bench, more than anyone on the roster. You will read that number elsewhere this week, and you should. I'll say it once and leave it there. Lineups get set before kickoff, not on Tuesday with the box score in hand, and they are Mike's to set.
What interests me more is the tone. A loss by less than two points, to a winless club, to your own kid, drops Fifth Quarter to 2-4, last in the Diablo and three games behind the Fumblers. An owner could be forgiven for being short about it. Mike wasn't. He answered quickly, on the record, specific and patient about his team, and then he made a family joke at his own expense. I take the joke as information, too. This one stings, and he has decided to carry it lightly.
The rest of his email shows how he thinks, and it is worth hearing in his words. On Halton: "I wasn't looking for a one-week rental. I want young players I can keep and develop." On the line now that Aidan Hutchinson is back from his bye: "Aidan is our anchor, Gracen earned his spot, and Mason comes back when he's healthy; we go by the injury report." Mason is Mason Graham, who sat out Week 6.
That matches what I have seen this week. Hutchinson is back with the first unit, and Halton is right behind him, not buried at the end of the line. There is something in a father talking about keeping and developing young players in the same email where he admits his son just beat him. I'll leave that one to you.
On the other side of the family, I asked Hana Kealoha, who covers Kamehameha, what the win means. She has watched that club lose for five weeks, and she isn't ready to call it a corner. Her read, offered as her opinion: one win by under two points is a floor, not a turn. It shows Kamehameha can win when Pitts and Ryland both have big days, she said, but it doesn't fix a running game leaning on Braelon Allen with Jeremiyah Love out. She also checked the schedule for me. Week 6 is the only meeting between the two Carrico clubs she can find through Week 14. Any rematch will have to wait for the playoffs, or for the turkey.
Here is the funny part. Nina Alvarez, who covers the Diablo, reached for the same word about Fifth Quarter earlier this week. Her opinion is that the ceiling is real and the floor is the problem. So by the reckoning of the two colleagues who watch them most closely, both Carrico clubs are staring at their floors this week.
I'd put it a little differently for Fifth Quarter, at least for Week 6. I think that loss came as much from who was available as from who was chosen: Kyle Monangai out, Hutchinson on a bye, Graham hurt. Some of that fixes itself. Some of it doesn't, and the week ahead is where we find out which.
Fifth Quarter hosts IR Kings, also 2-4, in Week 7. Monangai's toe is still the open question. "Ben Johnson calls him week to week with the toe, so I'll read Wednesday's report like everybody else," Mike said. Alvin Kamara is the starter, and Ollie Gordon II is back from his bye. After IR Kings come three straight division games, All Strong, Likely 2 Punt and the Fumblers, and at three games back, that stretch is where this season gets decided. Not at the dinner table.
Still, I keep coming back to the dinner table. This league runs on rivalries between people who barely know each other. This one is between a father and a son, and the only thing I know for sure about how it plays at home is what the father told me: he'll be hearing about it.
Thanksgiving is about five weeks off. By then Fifth Quarter will have played a handful more games, and Mike Carrico will have had time to work up a reply. For now his son has the last word, by a point and three quarters.

